Empty and untradeable order books no longer report `availability: live`
pricing.availability on GET /v1/markets/{market_id} meant one thing —
"every outcome carries a price" — and a price is not a market. An empty
AlphaArcade order book fell back to a stale catalog midpoint; a Predict market
quoted 0.01 / 0.99 published the arithmetic midpoint of that range; both
reported live. Sitting next to a venue with a real book, those numbers read
as an edge:
| event | Predict | our availability | Polymarket | apparent edge |
|---|---|---|---|---|
mlb-mia-wsh-2026-08-28 | MIA 0.515 | live | Miami 0.735 | 0.220 |
mlb-cin-chc-2026-08-28 | CIN 0.485 | live | Cincinnati 0.395 | 0.090 |
mlb-hou-nyy-2026-08-27 | HOU 0.500 | live | Houston 0.430 | 0.070 |
None of those edges existed. Each Predict quote came from a book tens of cents wide, on a venue that publishes, per market, exactly how wide a book it counts as liquidity.
A new indicative value now separates the two claims. live means every
outcome is priced and at least one outcome has a two-sided book the venue
itself treats as quoted. indicative means every outcome is priced but none of
those prices has such a book behind it — a mark, one side with nothing facing
it, or a two-sided book the venue's own spread threshold rejects. price,
bid, and ask are unchanged and nothing is nulled: the venue's numbers are
real information, and what changes is the claim made about them.
Three things drive the new grade:
- Predict's per-market
spreadThresholdis now read. It is the venue's own declaration of the widest bid/ask spread it counts as liquidity — the same number Predict's liquidity-reward rules tell makers to stay below. It is genuinely per-market: measured live across 6,122 open markets it took three values (0.06 on 4,828, 0.04 on 1,156, 0.03 on 16), so it cannot be a constant. 56% of two-sided Predict outcomes in that sample were quoted outside their own market's threshold. - An empty book is one answer, not two. AlphaArcade markets that never
traded carry no midpoint and already reported
no_quotes; markets whose book emptied out kept a stale one and reportedlive. Same upstream fact, so they now agree —no_quoteswhere there is no price,indicativewhere there is a mark. - One resting order is not a market. A book with a bid and no ask still
produces a price on both outcomes, and that is now
indicativeon every provider. Settled Polymarket markets, whose 1/0outcomePricesare resolution marks with no book at all, land there too.
Venues that publish no spread threshold get no invented one; only the
two-sidedness test applies to them. A Polymarket market with a real book on its
primary outcome stays live even though the other outcome carries a mark only,
because the market is genuinely quoted.
What breaks. indicative is a new enum value, so a client that switches
exhaustively on availability needs a branch for it, and markets that
previously reported live now report indicative. Code that filters on
availability == "live" will see fewer markets and should — that is the fix. If
you only need "is there a number here", the guarantee on price now covers
live and indicative: both promise a non-null price on every outcome.
Anything sized or arbitraged against a quote should read live alone, and take
the executable price from the venue's own book.
GET /v1/markets/{market_id} also gained an up-front statement of what the
pricing tier can and cannot support, so the limits are stated once at the top
rather than spread across six field descriptions.